Are Target-Date Funds Missing the Mark?

Target Date Funds (TDFs), also known as lifecycle or age-based funds, are a unique investment option designed specifically for retirement. They have become popular because they allow the investor to simply choose the fund that aligns with their expected retirement year, and the money will be invested in a diversified mix of assets that gradually shifts over time to become more conservative as you near retirement. It’s a “set it and forget it” strategy that takes the guesswork out of planning for your financial future.

However, is this the best strategy for planning for retirement? It is wise to weigh the pros and cons of this approach and speak with a financial professional about your particular needs before making a decision.

PROS

Simplicity: Target date investments simplify the process by choosing only one investment fund instead of several. This saves you the struggle of trying to figure out which investments suit your goals the best. The fund manager selects the assets for you that will make up your TDF.

Ease: They offer a simple, hands-off approach to saving for retirement. The portfolio manager will make changes to the investments for you as you approach your retirement date.

Diversification: TDFs typically invest in a mix of stocks, bonds, and other assets, offering instant diversification within a single fund. This can be appealing to beginner investors or people who don’t want to spend time researching and managing their portfolio.

CONS

Generalized: The investments may not align with your particular needs or level of risk you are comfortable with. Some critics of TDFs argue that they are too conservatively managed and therefore may not perform as well as an actively-managed fund could. Investors with a high-risk tolerance and are seeking maximum growth potential with their portfolio may be disappointed with TDFs.

Fees: TDFs may have higher fees than index funds or ETFs which can eat into your potential returns.

Limited Control: Investors have little control over what funds are included in their TDF. If you have specific requests for how your assets are invested then a TDF may not meet your expectations.

Withdrawal Challenges: The single fund nature of a TDF can be problematic when it comes time to begin withdrawing from the portfolio in retirement. Since stocks and bonds rarely peak or trough simultaneously, it’s usually better to sell either one or the other during withdrawals, rather than both at the same time. TDFs combine stocks and bonds, making it impossible to withdraw from just one asset class. This means you’ll always be forced to sell both stocks and bonds, even during market downturns. To address this issue, some TDFs split their investments into two or three portfolios (growth and income) specifically for withdrawals. However, this can lead to complex tax implications as you’ll need to consider the tax treatment of both asset classes when making withdrawals.

IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO DISCUSS YOUR FINANCIAL OPTIONS WITH A PROFESSIONAL, AXIAS IS HERE TO HELP. CONTACT US

6766959RG_Aug26